Red Right Daily

Truth in Freedom

Newsom’s Comments Create Debate

Newsom’s Comments Create Debate

Gavin Newsom’s recent comments on transgender athletes in female sports have ignited a firestorm within the Democratic Party, opening up a potential early divide ahead of the 2028 presidential race. By taking a stance that many in his party see as a sharp departure from progressive orthodoxy, Newsom has both stunned longtime allies and emboldened moderates who argue that Democrats have strayed too far into identity politics.

The California governor’s assertion that it is “deeply unfair” for transgender athletes to compete in female sports sent immediate shockwaves through Democratic circles. Within hours, prominent progressive figures, including former Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot and Rep. Pramila Jayapal, condemned Newsom’s remarks. Major LGBTQ+ advocacy groups, including the Human Rights Campaign, signaled that support for trans athletes would be a defining issue in the Democratic primaries, warning that any deviation from full-throated support for transgender rights could cost Newsom politically.

Yet, for moderate Democrats, Newsom’s position represents a long-overdue correction. Party strategists and lawmakers who have grown increasingly concerned about the political consequences of progressive social policies argue that the public—Democrats included—is largely in agreement with the notion that female sports should be reserved for biological women. Polling supports this sentiment: Pew Research recently found that two-thirds of Americans favor requiring transgender athletes to compete on teams that align with their birth sex.

Newsom’s comments were made during a podcast discussion with conservative activist Charlie Kirk—a move that, in itself, raised eyebrows among Democrats in Washington and Sacramento. While some quietly acknowledged that the governor was addressing an issue that has hurt the party electorally, others were left feeling betrayed. The backlash was swift among Democratic lawmakers in California, many of whom had long viewed Newsom as a reliable ally on LGBTQ+ issues.

His remarks also highlighted a broader strategic shift among potential 2028 contenders. Former Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg recently critiqued aspects of diversity initiatives, suggesting that their implementation had fueled backlash from Republicans. Illinois Gov. J.B. Pritzker, another possible White House hopeful, has proposed cutting a health benefit for certain noncitizen immigrants, citing a budget deficit. These moves reflect a growing concern among Democrats that issues of identity and inclusion, while important to the party’s progressive base, may be alienating a significant portion of voters.

Written by Mark Stevens - March 9, 2025